User:Unfocused
Unfocused: a Wikipedia user who is
- a semi-professional photographer.
- showing symptoms of undiagnosed ADD.
Liberal to Flaming Liberal?
With this edit, I think I've officially gone from "Liberal" to "Flaming Liberal". I welcome comments on my talk page.
Regarding Anonymous Posting
I had been posting anonymously because I feel it is more in keeping with the nature of Wikipedia: edits stand or fall on their own merits and the quality of the sources cited, rather than on the reputation of the poster.
For a while I posted using my account, but I've found it ultimately far less satisfying and have returned to anonymous editing.
Problems With VfD
I think I've figured out why some VfD are bothering me.
- The text of the VfD notice posted on the article page is hostile to new users.
- Rapid VfD is hostile to new users. New users who put up a simple starting page are being threatened to have their work deleted just as they first see their efforts displayed on screen.
- VfD is being used as a cleanup tag. I don't have a problem with that per se, but the VfD notice text should be changed if this is a legitimate use.
- VfD is being used as an "delete and recreate from scratch" decree. VfD should be applied only where an article has NO PLACE in Wikipedia. If a poor article has a place in Wikipedia, it should be cleaned up, or edited down to a bare stub, rather than eliminated. Leaving a stub acknowledges the utility of the article.
Tolerance before VfD
Jimbo Wales's comment re: tolerance of trivial articles on VfD This comment is especially relevant to an encyclopedia that never runs out of paper.