User:Daniel Mietchen/Slides/Editorial policies
| Wikipedia | Citizendium | Scholarpedia | Encyclopedia of Earth | Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics | PLoS ONE | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scope of site | All human knowledge | All human knowledge | Starting out with a few core areas but potentially all scholarly knowledge | Earth sciences | Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics | Starting out with biomedicine but potentially all scholarly knowledge |
| Original research | No | Possibly | No | No | Only | Only |
| License | CC-BY-SA | CC-BY-SA | mostly © but also CC-BY-NC-ND and GFDL | CC-BY-SA | CC-BY 
|
CC-BY
|
| Review model | Public; post publication | Public; post publication | Public; post publication | Non-public; pre publication | Public; post technical, pre formal publication[1] | Non-public; pre publication |
| Anonymity of authors | Default; site-wide | No; site-wide | No for primary authors, yes for other contributors; per article | No | No | No |
| Anonymity of reviewers | Default; site-wide | No; site-wide | Possible; per article | No | Possible; per comment | Yes |
| Minimal qualification to submit an article for review | None | Login | Invitation or community election, based on specialist expertise | Login | None | None |
| Minimal qualification to review | None | Generalist expertise (typically PhD) in the field | Invitation based on specialist expertise | Invitation based on specialist expertise | Invitation based on specialist expertise | Invitation based on specialist expertise |
| Minimal qualification to modify content before review | None | Login | Login | Login | None | None |
| Minimal qualification to modify reviewed content | None | Generalist expertise (typically PhD) in the field | Approval by curator (typically a well-known expert in the field) | Generalist expertise (typically PhD) in the field | N.A. | N.A. for PDF version; None for annotations |
| Minimal qualification to comment on reviewed content | None | Login | Login | Login | Login | Login |
| Metrics at site/ article/ contributor level | Built in but outsourced to reduce server load | Built in | Built in; see also the site-specific Scholar Index as well as Wikigenes | Built in | Yes (IF)/ Not public / No | Yes (IF)/ Public / No |
References
- ^ Pöschl, U. (2012). "Multi-Stage Open Peer Review: Scientific Evaluation Integrating the Strengths of Traditional Peer Review with the Virtues of Transparency and Self-Regulation". Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience. 6. doi:10.3389/fncom.2012.00033.
{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: unflagged free DOI (link)