User talk:Victor9876: Difference between revisions
Victor9876 (talk | contribs) ← Created page with 'Hello!' |
Wildhartlivie (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Hello! |
Hello! |
||
Your NOR point might be valid if the Martinez book was being used as a reference for a fact or quote being used otherwise in the article. However, all that the reference is being used for is to verify the statement "In 2003, Martinez published his memoirs, entitled, ''They Call Me Ranger Ray: From the UT Tower Sniper to Corruption in South Texas''." It makes no difference whatsoever whether his memoir was published by a vanity press or by the most prominent publishing house in the world. It's only being used for issues of verifiability of the statement and would not qualify as spam in either case, which is the reason you gave in your edit summary for its removal. The portion of the edit summary regarding quotes refers to your having made bold quotes [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Charles_Whitman&diff=prev&oldid=244079234#The_University_of_Texas_and_the_Governor.27s_Report_of_August_8.2C_1966 here], which has nothing to do with the Martinez book. [[User:Wildhartlivie|Wildhartlivie]] ([[User talk:Wildhartlivie|talk]]) 03:38, 13 October 2008 (UTC) |
Revision as of 03:38, 13 October 2008
Hello!
Your NOR point might be valid if the Martinez book was being used as a reference for a fact or quote being used otherwise in the article. However, all that the reference is being used for is to verify the statement "In 2003, Martinez published his memoirs, entitled, They Call Me Ranger Ray: From the UT Tower Sniper to Corruption in South Texas." It makes no difference whatsoever whether his memoir was published by a vanity press or by the most prominent publishing house in the world. It's only being used for issues of verifiability of the statement and would not qualify as spam in either case, which is the reason you gave in your edit summary for its removal. The portion of the edit summary regarding quotes refers to your having made bold quotes here, which has nothing to do with the Martinez book. Wildhartlivie (talk) 03:38, 13 October 2008 (UTC)