QTI
The IMS Question and Test Interoperability specification (QTI) defines a standard format for the representation of assessment content and results, supporting the exchange of this material between authoring and delivery systems, repositories and other learning management systems. It allows assessment materials to be authored and delivered on multiple systems interchangeably. It is, therefore, designed to facilitate interoperability between systems.[1]
The specification consists of a data model that defines the structure of questions, assessments and results from questions and assessments together with an XML data binding that essentially defines a language for interchanging questions and other assessment material. The XML binding is used for exchanging questions between different authoring tools and by publishers. The assessment and results parts of the specification are less widely used.
As can be seen below, the standard is mainly implemented by commercial products, few open source assessment systems support it and the most popular open source learning management systems (Moodle does not support it and Canvas only supports the old 1.2 version) limit support. The fact that you have to register to download the specs begs the openness of the standard.
Background
QTI was produced by the IMS Global Learning Consortium (IMS GLC), which is an industry and academic consortium that develops specifications for interoperable learning technology. QTI was inspired by the need for interoperability in question design, and to avoid people losing or having to re-type questions when technology changes. Developing and validating good questions can be time consuming, and it's desirable to be able to create them in a platform and technology neutral format. IMS has less than 800 members and is not the voice for the entire industry. You cannot use the QTI name in anything other than an RFP according to their website.[2]
QTI version 1.0 was materially based on a proprietary Questions Markup Language (QML) language defined by QuestionMark, but the language has evolved over the years and can now describe almost any reasonable question that one might want to describe. (QML is still in use by Questionmark).
Version 2.0 was finalized in 2005 and addressed the item (that is, the individual question) level of the specification only. A draft version of Version 2.1, which covered the structure of tests and results, was also released in 2005. But because Version 2.0 did not address test-level issues and was not compatible with Version 1, and because 2.1 was still under development, adoption of Version 2 was retarded. This was compounded in 2009 when IMS GLC withdrew the Version 2.1 draft and advised the user community that the only version "fully endorsed" by IMS GLC was 1.2.1, in effect also deprecating Version 2.0. Despite this, after several more drafts, 2.1 was finalized and released in 2012.
The current version is 2.2, which was finalized in 2015, and has subsequently had two minor revisions, 2.2.1 and 2.2.2, the latest of which was in November 2017. Version 2.2 updated and improved integration with W3C standards such as HTML5, SSML, PLS, CSS, ARIA, and MathML, and otherwise made relatively small changes to the Version 2.1 core specification.
Version 2.x is a significant improvement on Version 1, defining a new underlying interaction model. It is also notable for its significantly greater degree of integration with other specifications (some of which did not exist during the production of v1): the specification addresses the relationship with IMS Content Packaging v1.2, IEEE Learning Object Metadata, IMS Learning Design, IMS Simple Sequencing and other standards such as XHTML. It also provides guidance on representing context-specific usage data and information to support the migration of content from earlier versions of the specification.
Version 3 is now available. IMS is now called 1EdTech.
Certification
IMS offers certification of compliance to QTI standards, as noted in the table below. However, it is only offered to members of the consortium, which costs US$1,000 to US$7,500 per year.[3] There is also a cost to certify your software in addition to the Membership cost. This effectively leaves open source projects without the ability to be certified.
Timeline
| Date | Version | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| March 1999 | 0.5 | Internal to IMS |
| February 2000 | 1.0 public draft | |
| May 2000 | 1.0 final release | |
| August 2000 | 1.01 | |
| March 2001 | 1.1 | |
| January 2002 | 1.2 | |
| March 2003 | 1.2.1 addendum | |
| September 2003 | 2.0 charter | Initiation of working group |
| January 2005 | 2.0 final release | |
| January 2006 | 2.1 public draft | |
| July 2006 | 2.1 public draft version 2 | |
| March 2009 | 2.1 draft withdrawn, 2.0 deprecated | |
| September 2012 | 2.1 final release | |
| September 2015 | 2.2 final release | |
| November 2017 | 2.2.2 revision of 2.2 | |
| May 2022 | 3.0 final release |
Applications with IMS QTI support
| Name | QTI version | Type of tool | Comment | License | Certified |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| assessmentQ | 2.1 | Intuitive web-based e-assessment platform, supporting authoring, delivery, grading, reporting, analytics and certification. | Supports import of QTI 2.1 files, PDF, XLIFF and Excel files. | Propietary | No |
| ATutor | 1.2, 2.1 | LCMS | QTI 1.2; QTI 2.1 export remains experimental [4] ATutor is no longer maintained -greggray Nov 5, 2021 | GPL | No |
| Canvas by Instructure | 2.1 | LMS | 2.1, Import and export of QTI files, Support of authoring, item banking, and content delivery. Since September 2023, New Quizzes supports exporting QTI 1.2.[5] | AGPL | Yes[6] |
| CSGrader | not stated | Digital Education tool for creating programing assignments for schools, universities, and bootcamps | Does not support QTI | Proprietary | No |
| Chamilo | 1.2, 2.0 | LMS/LCMS | export QTI 1.2 & 2.0, import QTI 2.0 (1.2 disabled by default but available) (supports SCORM 1.2) | GPL | No |
| Classera | 2.2 | authoring | Proprietary | No | |
| Cognero | 1.2, 2.1 | online assessment system providing online authoring, delivery, sharing, and reporting | Import and export QTI 1.2, export QTI 2.1 [7] | Proprietary | Yes[6] |
| Desire2Learn | 1.2 | LMS | can export IMS QTI 1.2, an online tool provides QTI 1.2 import | Proprietary | No |
| FastTest | 1.2, 1.2 (Pearson), 2.1 | Single ecosystem for item authoring, form assembly, Angoff studies, online delivery, reporting, psychometric analysis, and computerized adaptive testing with item response theory | Supports both imports and exports | Proprietary | No |
| GETMARKED | 2.1, 1.2 | Browser-based AI tool that automatically convert any docx or pdf quiz or exam into QTI. Does not require pdf or word document to conform to any specific format. | Supports exports to QTI 2.1, QTI 1.2, Blackboard Pool, Google Classroom and Moodle XML. | Proprietary | No |
| GradeMaker | 2.1, 2.2 | High stakes exam authoring tool for national Awarding Bodies and Higher Education with comprehensive workflow, versioning and auditing. | Supports exports to QTI file and publishing direct to test players | Proprietary | No |
| ILIAS | not stated | LMS | supports SCORM 1.2 and SCORM 2004 | GPL | No |
| IMC - more than learning | 1.2 | LMS | Supports both imports and exports | Proprietary | No |
| Inspera Assessment | 2.1, 2.2 | Digital e-Assessment tool supporting authoring, delivering, marking and reporting, as well as providing learning analytics, computerized adaptive testing with item response theory. | Supports exporting and importing tests and items in QTI 2.1 and 2.2. The tests and items authored in Inspera's system are stored and conducted using QTI 2.2. | Proprietary | No |
| itslearning | 2.1 | LMS | Supports QTI import | Proprietary | Yes[6] |
| Learnosity | 2.1 | Suite of APIs, including assessment item rendering, assessment delivery, authoring and reporting tools | supports both imports and exports | Proprietary | No |
| Lectora | not stated | authoring tool | supports AICC, SCORM 1.2 and SCORM 2004 | Proprietary | No |
| OpenOLAT | 2.1 | LMS / LCMS | Implementation based on QTI 2.1, import/export QTI 2.1 supported, 12 different question types. | Apache | No |
| Online Learning And Training | 1.2 | LCMS | QTI 2.1 compliance can be achieved with ONYX as plugin | Apache | No |
| ONYX Testsuite | 1.2, 2.1 | assessment suite, consists of authoring, delivery and reporting tool | based on QTI 2.1, import/export QTI 1.2, import Blackboard/WebCT/OLAT | Proprietary | Yes[8] |
| ONYX WebEditor | 1.2, 2.1 | online authoring tool (incl. converter and item-bank) | based on QTI 2.1, import/export QTI 1.2, import Blackboard/WebCT/OLAT | Proprietary | Yes[8] |
| QST Quiz/Survey/Test | 1/2/3 | Complete Assessment Solution - Online and mobile, very scalable and secure. Question Bank, GradeBook, Free. Convert questions to different formats. Authoring, Delivery, Marking. | Import QTI 1/2/3 files, Export QTI 2.2, Import/Export Moodle XML. From a simple mobile quiz to full proctored desktop testing to detailed analysis. | GPL | No |
| qtimigration | 1.0, 2.0 | converts QTI v1 to QTI v2 | BSD | No | |
| QTI-SDK | 2.0, 2.1, 2.2 | Software Development Kit aiming at providing tools to manipulate and deliver QTI assessments. | An IMS QTI Software Development Kit for PHP 5.5 and higher supporting a wide range of features described by the IMS QTI specification family. | GPL | No |
| QTIWorks (link is dead) | 2.1 | system for managing, verifying and delivering assessments | Development on system has ended | BSD | No |
| QuestBase | not stated | authoring tool and delivery system | free online tool that can import IMS QTI | Proprietary | No |
| QuestionMark Perception | not stated | authoring tool and delivery system | can export IMS QTI, an online tool provides QTI 1.2 import | Proprietary | No |
| Question Writer 2.0 Publisher Edition | 1.2 | authoring tool | exports as QTI 1.2 and SCORM 1.2 | Proprietary | No |
| Question Writer 3.5 Professional | 1.2 | authoring tool | exports as QTI 1.2 and SCORM 1.2. Also specific QTI export for Pearson VUE. | Proprietary | No |
| Rogō | 1.2 | e-Assessment | Imports/exports QTI 1.2 format questions | GPL | No |
| Sakai | 1.2 | LMS | import and export QTI 1.2 [9][10] | ECL | No |
| SharePoint LMS | 1.2 | LMS | can export IMS QTI 1.2, an online tool provides QTI 1.2 import | Proprietary | No |
| TAO[11] | 2.1 | computer-based assessment platform | Only package to achieve all four areas of compliance within a single platform, Content (Validity of the packages produced/ingested), Authoring (Ability to author and export valid QTI Items & Tests), Delivery (Ability to deliver QTI Items & Tests), Item / Test Bank (Ability to store, import, export QTI Items & Tests) | GPL | Yes[8] |
| Trifork - QTI Assessment Delivery Engine | 2.2 & 3.0 | Delivery System | QTI 2.2 & 3.0 | Proprietary | No |
| Trifork - QTI Editor | 2.2 & 3.0 | Authoring tool | QTI 2.2 & 3.0 | Proprietary | No |
See also
References
- ^ Effective Practice with e-Assessment guide, p.44
- ^ "IMS GLOBAL LEARNING CONSORTIUM, INC. SPECIFICATION DOCUMENT LICENSE | IMS Global Learning Consortium".
- ^ Alliance membership
- ^ ATutor Question and Test Interoperability Support in ATutor Wiki.
- ^ Export QTI announcement in New Quizzes
- ^ a b c "Product Certifications | IMS Global".
- ^ "Cognero Features". cognero.com. Madeira Station LLC. 2013. Archived from the original on 2014-04-07. Retrieved 2013-08-09.
[...] imports QTI 1.2 and exports QTI 1.2 and 2.1 [...]
- ^ a b c "IMS GLC: CC/LTI Conformance Directory". imsglobal.org. IMS Global. Retrieved 2014-06-08.
- ^ Sakai Import-Export Features.
- ^ Tests and Quizzes (aka. SAMigo).
- ^ "Assessment Software | Open Source Assessment Platform | TAO Testing".
External links
- IMS Global Learning Consortium: IMS Question & Test Interoperability Specification
- List of software that implement QTI
- Complete Guide to QTI