Avot of Rabbi Natan, also known as Avot de-Rabbi Nathan (ARN) (Jewish Babylonian Aramaic: אבות דרבי נתן), the first and longest of the minor tractates of the Talmud, is a Jewish aggadic work probably compiled in the geonic era (c.700–900 CE). It is a commentary on an early form of the Mishnah. It has come down in two recensions (or versions): a standard printed edition, and a second published with 48 chapters by Solomon Schechter, who designated the two recensions as A and B respectively.
Despite being one of the minor tractates, it more greatly resembles a late midrash. It may be technically designated as a homiletical exposition of the Mishnaic tractate Pirkei Avot, having for its foundation an older recension of that tractate. It also may be considered as a kind of tosefta or gemarah to the Mishna Avot, which does not possess a traditional gemarah.
ARN contains many teachings, proverbs, and incidents that are not found anywhere else in the early rabbinical literature.[1] Other rabbinical sayings appear in a more informal style than what is found in Pirkei Avot.
Recensions
Touching its original form, its age, and its dependence on earlier or later recensions of the Mishnah, there are many opinions, all of which are discussed in S. Schechter's introduction. There are two recensions of this work, one of which is usually printed with the Babylonian Talmud in the appendix to Seder Nezikin [the sixteenth volume], preceding the so-called Minor Treatises, and another, which, until the late 19th century, existed in manuscript only. In 1887 Solomon Schechter published the two recensions in parallel columns, contributing to the edition a critical introduction and valuable notes. There were likely other recensions as well, since the medieval rabbis quote from other versions.
In order to distinguish the two recensions, the one printed with the Talmud may be called A; and the other, B. The former is divided into forty-one chapters, and the latter into forty-eight. Schechter has proved that recension B is cited only by Spanish authors. Rashi knows of recension A only.
A Hebrew manuscript of Avot de-Rabbi Nathan is today housed at the Bodleian Library in Oxford, England, under the classification MS Oxford (Bodleiana) Heb. c. 24.[2] In addition, MS Parma (Palatina) 2785 (de Rossi 327; Uncastillo/Spain, 1289), being a more precise copy of Avot de-Rabbi Nathan, has been used to correct errors in recension B.[2]
Contents
The content of the two recensions differ from each other considerably, although the method is the same in both. The separate teachings of the Mishnah Avot are generally taken as texts, which are either briefly explained—the ethical lessons contained therein being supported by reference to Biblical passages—or fully illustrated by narratives and legends. Sometimes long digressions are made by introducing subjects connected only loosely with the text. This method may be illustrated by the following example: Commenting on the teaching of Simon the Just which designates charity as one of the three pillars on which the world rests,[3] Avot de-Rabbi Nathan reads as follows:
How [does the world rest] on charity? Behold, the prophet said in the name of the Lord, 'I desired charity [mercy], and not sacrifice.'[4] The world was created only by charity [mercy], as is said, 'Mercy shall be built up for ever'[5] (or, as the rabbis translate this passage, 'The world is built on mercy'). Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakai, accompanied by R. Joshua, once passed Jerusalem [after its fall]. While looking upon the city and the ruins of the Temple, R. Joshua exclaimed, 'Woe unto us, that the holy place is destroyed which atoned for our sins!' R. Yochanan replied, 'My son, do not grieve on this account, for we have another atonement for our sins; it is charity, as is said, I desired charity, and not sacrifice.[6]
The chapters of the two recensions of Avot de-Rabbi Nathan correspond with those of the Mishnah Avot as follows:
Chapters 1-11 of recension A and chapters 1-23 of recension B correspond with Pirkei Avot 1:1-11, dealing with saying of the Zugoth.
Chapters 12-19 of A and chapters 24-29 of B correspond with Pirkei Avot 1:12-18 and chapter 2, dealing with the teachings of Hillel, Shammai, Yohanan ben Zakkai and his disciples
Chapters 20-30 of A and chapters 30-35 of B correspond with Pirkei Avot chapters 3-4, an independent mishnaic collection
Chapters 31-41 of A and chapters 36-48 of B correspond with Pirkei Avot chapter 5, a collection of anonymous statements related by form
Nathan the Babylonian, whose name appears in the title of the work under treatment, cannot possibly have been its only author, since he flourished about the middle of the 2nd century, or a generation prior to the author of the Mishnah. Besides, several authorities are quoted who flourished a long time after R. Nathan; for instance, Rabbi Joshua ben Levi. The designation "De-Rabbi Nathan" may be explained by the circumstance that R. Nathan is one of the first authorities mentioned in the opening chapter of the work (but not the first, that being Yose ha-Galili). Perhaps the school of the tannaite R. Nathan originated the work, however. Probably due to political differences that Rabbi Nathan had with Shimon ben Gamliel, Rabbi Nathan's name does not appear in the version of Avot compiled by redactor of the Mishna Rebbi (the son of the aforementioned Shimon ben Gamliel). However, it is known that Rabbi Nathan made an independent collection (Cashdan 1965), and it is possible that Avot de-Rabbi Nathan derives from that source.
It is also called Tosefta to Avot.[7] The two recensions of the work in their present shape evidently have different authors, but who they were cannot be ascertained. Probably they belonged to the period of the Geonim, between the 8th and 9th centuries.
Date
Through the majority of the 20th century, it was believed that the ARN dated from the 7th to 9th centuries. However, the work of Saldarini,[8] which proposed a date close to the compilation of the Mishnah in the third century, opened up a range of proposals for dating the text to earlier periods. Today, it is widely acknowledged that there are difficulties in dating the two versions of the ARN[9][10][11] and current proposals for the date of the text vary within a range of five centuries, roughly from an earliest possible dating to the third century (B is usually the earlier dated one and some believe it predates the Babylonian Talmud), with the latest possible dating roughly in the eighth century.[9][12]
Translations
A Latin translation of Abot de-Rabbi Nathan was published by Franz Tayler, London, 1654: Tractatus de Patribus Rabbi Nathan Auctore, in Linguam Latinam Translatus.
Schechter gives the commentaries to Avot de-Rabbi Nathan in his edition.[13] Emendations were made by Benjamin Motal.[14] Commentaries have been written by Eliezer Lipman of Zamość, Zolkiev, 1723; by Elijah ben Abraham with notes by the Vilna Gaon,[15] by Abraham Witmand,[16] and by Joshua Falk Lisser.[17] Lisser's edition is reprinted in the Vilna Talmud.
^ abBerner, Christoph (2011). "Quotations from Avot de Rabbi Nathan B in MS Oxford (Bodleiana) Heb. c. 24". Jewish Studies Quarterly. 18 (3). Mohr Siebeck GmbH & Co. KG: 217–265. doi:10.1628/094457011797248462. JSTOR41289143.
^Saldarini, A.J. (1975). The Fathers according to Rabbi Nathan (Abot de Rabbi Nathan), Version B: A translation and commentary. Brill. pp. 1–16.
^ abReuling, Hanneke (2006). After Eden: church fathers and rabbis on Genesis 3:16-21. Jewish and Christian perspectives series. Leiden ; Boston: Brill. pp. 280–281, esp. n. 7. ISBN 978-90-04-14638-9.
^Kister, Menahem (1998). Studies in Avot de-Rabbi Nathan: text, redaction and interpretation. pp. 217–222.
^Fishbane, Simcha; Goldscheider, Calvin; Lightstone, Jack N. (2021). Exploring Mishnah's world(s): social scientific approaches. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 195, n. 27. ISBN 978-3-030-53573-5.
^Solomon Schechter, Abot de-Rabbi Nathan, Vienna, 1887; 27 et seq.
^In his collectanea, called Tummat Yesharim (Venice, 1622).
Cashdan, Eli (1965), "Introduction", in A. Cohen (ed.), The Minor Tractates of the Talmud: Massektoth Ketannoth, Volume I, London: Soncino Press.
This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Singer, Isidore; et al., eds. (1901–1906). "Abot de-Rabbi Nathan". The Jewish Encyclopedia. New York: Funk & Wagnalls.. The JE cites the following works
Leopold Zunz, Gottesdienstliche Vorträge der Juden,, 1st ed., pp. 108 et seq.;
Solomon Taussig, Neweh Shalom I, Munich, 1872, in which pamphlet a part of Abot de-Rabbi Nathan, recension B, was for the first time published, according to a manuscript of the Munich Library;
This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Singer, Isidore; et al., eds. (1901–1906). "Abot de-Rabbi Nathan". The Jewish Encyclopedia. New York: Funk & Wagnalls.. The JE cites the following works
